Page 1 of 2

Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 9:59:32 pm
by Cecilia
Honestly, half the cast should come back. We're gold and it'd LOVE to be Stranded with you all again and make legends of ourselves <3

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 9:59:59 pm
by Cecilia
Cecilia wrote:Honestly, half the cast should come back. We're gold and it'd LOVE to be Stranded with you all again and make legends of ourselves <3


I'd*

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:00:01 pm
by Cassandra
me tbh

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:01:07 pm
by Cecilia
Cassandra wrote:me tbh


You were the queen and only got 9th place smh, I can see the viewers rioting in the streets already.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:02:24 pm
by Cassandra
I think it stops there, though. I was the best and everyone else was my pawn. The next season should just be me and I automatically win.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:03:26 pm
by Cecilia
Cassandra wrote:I think it stops there, though. I was the best and everyone else was my pawn. The next season should just be me and I automatically win.


Basically Stranded Redemption Islands. You and 17 Rebeccas. That's it.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:04:47 pm
by Flicka
I think Cassandra, Jessica and Cecilia are the biggest contenders for being brought back and if she doesn't win, then Candice as well.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:05:55 pm
by Cecilia
Flicka wrote:I think Cassandra, Jessica and Cecilia are the biggest contenders for being brought back and if she doesn't win, then Candice as well.


Thank you<3 I would add Stephannie. And yourself, especially if there's a Second Chance theme.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:07:52 pm
by Jessica
Flicka wrote:I think Cassandra, Jessica and Cecilia are the biggest contenders for being brought back and if she doesn't win, then Candice as well.


Except we'd be immediately cast out. Everyone kind of distrusts/dislikes us since they all, y'know, got us out. Except Stacy. She's still my #1

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:12:35 pm
by Flicka
Cecilia wrote:
Flicka wrote:I think Cassandra, Jessica and Cecilia are the biggest contenders for being brought back and if she doesn't win, then Candice as well.


Thank you<3 I would add Stephannie. And yourself, especially if there's a Second Chance theme.


Thanks. I don't want to speak for Stephannie, but I think a second chance type theme is the only situation where I would be considered to come back with the whole, "you seemed like a good player, but your time seemed cut short" type of feeling.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:14:37 pm
by Jessica
Jessica wrote:
Flicka wrote:I think Cassandra, Jessica and Cecilia are the biggest contenders for being brought back and if she doesn't win, then Candice as well.


Except we'd be immediately cast out. Everyone kind of distrusts/dislikes us since they all, y'know, got us out. Except Stacy. She's still my #1


Didn't understand what we meant. I think that everyone post-merge deserves to return...besides Rocky and Rebecca BECAUSE THEY DESERVE TO WIN AMILEFT LADIES?

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:16:10 pm
by Cecilia
If Rebecca wins I hope the prize is enough for her to move to USA.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:17:46 pm
by Stephannie
girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:20:48 pm
by Jessica
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


I mean, I guess for second chance we all did pretty well our first.

However, with 3 people quitting, the only pre-merge boots were Adam, Papa, Mookie, Anthony, and JP. Out of the 5 of them, Anthony was the best. JP could come back too, I suppose, but I didn't see too much from any of them for a real impression.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:20:56 pm
by Cecilia
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


True, what would have happened in a tie? Re vote?

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:22:22 pm
by Nate
Cecilia wrote:
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


True, what would have happened in a tie? Re vote?


Yeah it would have been a revote.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:24:30 pm
by Nate
Also assuming they're using the Second Chance label similarly to the show and they don't have that many seasons to pull back on, CiCi/Cass/Jess are locks, Steph is probably up there, apparently Anthony was noteworthy so he's also probably up there, and I'm prob a replacement for somebody on Day 5.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:25:40 pm
by Nate
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


also Steph I think we're both now in the "screwed because somebody who's name starts with the letter R didn't vote in time" club.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:28:38 pm
by Jessica
Nate wrote:Also assuming they're using the Second Chance label similarly to the show and they don't have that many seasons to pull back on, CiCi/Cass/Jess are locks, Steph is probably up there, apparently Anthony was noteworthy so he's also probably up there, and I'm prob a replacement for somebody on Day 5.


Literally the season would happen the exact same. We'd all be friends until the merge, then we'd take each other down until only the goats and followers remained.

Re: Who should come back?

PostPosted: Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:31:57 pm
by Stephannie
Nate wrote:
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


also Steph I think we're both now in the "screwed because somebody who's name starts with the letter R didn't vote in time" club.

icon_no