Who should come back?

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Stephannie » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:33:37 pm

Jessica wrote:
Nate wrote:Also assuming they're using the Second Chance label similarly to the show and they don't have that many seasons to pull back on, CiCi/Cass/Jess are locks, Steph is probably up there, apparently Anthony was noteworthy so he's also probably up there, and I'm prob a replacement for somebody on Day 5.


Literally the season would happen the exact same. We'd all be friends until the merge, then we'd take each other down until only the goats and followers remained.


tbh one of the main reasons I didn't work with you at the swap was numbers. I didn't want to flip off Svinoy 2.0 after they were just super loyal to me (with the exception of Liliana... but you guys didn't want to vote her out).


I kept saying in confessionals that I wished we had been on the same tribe sooner, because I think we BOTH would have gone farther in this game working together.
User avatar
Stephannie
Jury
 
Posts: 972
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:43:40 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Jessica » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:36:05 pm

Stephannie wrote:tbh one of the main reasons I didn't work with you at the swap was numbers. I didn't want to flip off Svinoy 2.0 after they were just super loyal to me (with the exception of Liliana... but you guys didn't want to vote her out).


I kept saying in confessionals that I wished we had been on the same tribe sooner, because I think we BOTH would have gone farther in this game working together.


We did want to vote her out in the next round. We could've done it too since you and Flicka were super close. But instead you decided "let's make Svinoy super solid". Had you taken out Lil, you could've easily blindsided me later. I honestly trusted you after you took out JP because you said so...then you did it again and I made it my goal to send you out.
User avatar
Jessica
Jury
 
Posts: 954
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:21:51 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Stephannie » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:41:13 pm

Jessica wrote:
Stephannie wrote:tbh one of the main reasons I didn't work with you at the swap was numbers. I didn't want to flip off Svinoy 2.0 after they were just super loyal to me (with the exception of Liliana... but you guys didn't want to vote her out).


I kept saying in confessionals that I wished we had been on the same tribe sooner, because I think we BOTH would have gone farther in this game working together.


We did want to vote her out in the next round. We could've done it too since you and Flicka were super close. But instead you decided "let's make Svinoy super solid". Had you taken out Lil, you could've easily blindsided me later. I honestly trusted you after you took out JP because you said so...then you did it again and I made it my goal to send you out.


Flicka helped me so incredibly on Svinoy 2.0 that I would have never been able to vote her out after what we'd been through, so when you kept saying that it pretty much had to be Flicka I wasn't able to go through with it.


And I actually thought about the Anthony vote for a while.
The main reason, though, was because I didn't think you trusted me after lying and you kept saying: "Liliana lies! She can't be trusted!" which were all things that could be said about me icon_lol
So I thought it was a "one strike and you're out" deal so I wasn't sure if you were lying to be about Liliana... i.e. what if you tell me to vote Liliana to split my votes and then you bring in Liliana and it's 3 votes me, 1 vote Anthony, 1 vote Liliana.

(i.e. I was paranoid and wanted to play it safe right before the merge).

(
User avatar
Stephannie
Jury
 
Posts: 972
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:43:40 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Cecilia » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:43:18 pm

Honestly I'm super mad with my placing. 10th in a season with 3 quits? Ugh.
User avatar
Cecilia
Jury
 
Posts: 830
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:41:16 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Nate » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:47:35 pm

also how funny would it be if Candice gets out next?
It would be a funny thing that would hold true to the season
User avatar
Nate
Jury
 
Posts: 666
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:42:26 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Caryn » Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:49:26 pm

I was supposed to be a returning player this season, but Probst thought it would be unfair since I'm the only 3 time winner this series has had.

Consider yourselves lucky.
User avatar
Caryn
 
Posts: 105
Joined: Mon Jul 15, 2013 8:06:20 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Nate » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:13:48 pm

Caryn wrote:I was supposed to be a returning player this season, but Probst thought it would be unfair since I'm the only 3 time winner this series has had.

Consider yourselves lucky.


so the opposite of Second Chances?
User avatar
Nate
Jury
 
Posts: 666
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:42:26 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Flicka » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:19:48 pm

Jessica wrote:
Stephannie wrote:tbh one of the main reasons I didn't work with you at the swap was numbers. I didn't want to flip off Svinoy 2.0 after they were just super loyal to me (with the exception of Liliana... but you guys didn't want to vote her out).


I kept saying in confessionals that I wished we had been on the same tribe sooner, because I think we BOTH would have gone farther in this game working together.


We did want to vote her out in the next round. We could've done it too since you and Flicka were super close. But instead you decided "let's make Svinoy super solid". Had you taken out Lil, you could've easily blindsided me later. I honestly trusted you after you took out JP because you said so...then you did it again and I made it my goal to send you out.


Just want to put my two cents in there. I didn't want to vote out JP the TC he left. I believe you called me out that night when I said I wanted to vote for JP and then I said I wanted to vote out Anthony. I only voted for JP that night because Steph, Lil and Rocky for some reason weren't going to vote for Anthony. I liked JP and did trust him to a certain extent, but it made no sense to make it a 3-3-1 vote.

After that, I figured you were so pissed at me for getting JP out and because you didn't PM me after that tribal council (to be fair, I didn't PM you either), I figured, okay, this girl is definitely coming after me next, why would she work with me? Anthony then told me that he was willing to work with me and that he and you would be voting for Liliana and that if I did too, it would at least be a 3-3 tie. I may be remembering incorrectly, but I don't know if Steph and I talked about voting Liliana out at that point. It definitely was in our heads before the 2nd tribe swap, but at that point, I was too comfortable in my four person alliance with Steph, Lil and Rocky and making to the merge and I kept saying to them that as long as we vote together, we're pretty much guaranteed to make it to the merge.

I mean, I don't know if I was Steph's, but she was MY closest ally in the game and was the only person I trusted 100%, Rocky would pretty much do anything I told him to and I felt that Liliana would do whatever we said at that point because she would do whatever to make sure it just wasn't her getting voted out. My plan was to get you out both of the tribal councils we went to on Svinoy 3.0, but you kept winning those damn immunities. Haha. So JP and Anthony were the casualties.

Looking back now, of course, it probably would have benefited me and Steph if we voted Liliana out the night Anthony left, because it may have put us in a better position with you and would have possibly helped us last longer in the merge. But, it's probably my fault that I just got too comfortable in the numbers I had and was sort of playing to make it to the merge and didn't think a lot further than that. It was all about, "Just make it to the merge and you'll figure out what to do then when the time comes". In hindsight, I definitely should have talked to Steph about seriously considering voting out Liliana because we both probably would have done better than being the first two members of the jury.

Also, I figured that if you weren't coming after me, you were coming after Steph, and I would have NEVER voted against Steph unless it was me or her. Then we tried the fake idol plan and it ALMOST worked. But it didn't.
User avatar
Flicka
Jury
 
Posts: 384
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:41:37 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Jessica » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:23:44 pm

Flicka wrote:
Jessica wrote:
Stephannie wrote:tbh one of the main reasons I didn't work with you at the swap was numbers. I didn't want to flip off Svinoy 2.0 after they were just super loyal to me (with the exception of Liliana... but you guys didn't want to vote her out).


I kept saying in confessionals that I wished we had been on the same tribe sooner, because I think we BOTH would have gone farther in this game working together.


We did want to vote her out in the next round. We could've done it too since you and Flicka were super close. But instead you decided "let's make Svinoy super solid". Had you taken out Lil, you could've easily blindsided me later. I honestly trusted you after you took out JP because you said so...then you did it again and I made it my goal to send you out.


Just want to put my two cents in there. I didn't want to vote out JP the TC he left. I believe you called me out that night when I said I wanted to vote for JP and then I said I wanted to vote out Anthony. I only voted for JP that night because Steph, Lil and Rocky for some reason weren't going to vote for Anthony. I liked JP and did trust him to a certain extent, but it made no sense to make it a 3-3-1 vote.

After that, I figured you were so pissed at me for getting JP out and because you didn't PM me after that tribal council (to be fair, I didn't PM you either), I figured, okay, this girl is definitely coming after me next, why would she work with me? Anthony then told me that he was willing to work with me and that he and you would be voting for Liliana and that if I did too, it would at least be a 3-3 tie. I may be remembering incorrectly, but I don't know if Steph and I talked about voting Liliana out at that point. It definitely was in our heads before the 2nd tribe swap, but at that point, I was too comfortable in my four person alliance with Steph, Lil and Rocky and making to the merge and I kept saying to them that as long as we vote together, we're pretty much guaranteed to make it to the merge.

I mean, I don't know if I was Steph's, but she was MY closest ally in the game and was the only person I trusted 100%, Rocky would pretty much do anything I told him to and I felt that Liliana would do whatever we said at that point because she would do whatever to make sure it just wasn't her getting voted out. My plan was to get you out both of the tribal councils we went to on Svinoy 3.0, but you kept winning those damn immunities. Haha. So JP and Anthony were the casualties.

Looking back now, of course, it probably would have benefited me and Steph if we voted Liliana out the night Anthony left, because it may have put us in a better position with you and would have possibly helped us last longer in the merge. But, it's probably my fault that I just got too comfortable in the numbers I had and was sort of playing to make it to the merge and didn't think a lot further than that. It was all about, "Just make it to the merge and you'll figure out what to do then when the time comes". In hindsight, I definitely should have talked to Steph about seriously considering voting out Liliana because we both probably would have done better than being the first two members of the jury.

Also, I figured that if you weren't coming after me, you were coming after Steph, and I would have NEVER voted against Steph unless it was me or her. Then we tried the fake idol plan and it ALMOST worked. But it didn't.

It's funny because you're the reason I made it through JP's elimination. Posting your damn idol told me "FUCK THIS I AIN'T PLAYING DUMB"
User avatar
Jessica
Jury
 
Posts: 954
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:21:51 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Flicka » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:35:46 pm

Jessica, you have no idea how many times I have looked back at that tribal council and think, "SON OF A BITCH! WHY DID I NOT WAIT UNTIL AFTER EVERYONE COULD PLAY THEIR NECKLACES BEFORE I SHOWED EVERYONE THE IDOL?!"

The original plan in my moment of anger and being pumped up and everyone telling me that I'm going to be voted out was, "I know Jessica is the one that is trying to get everyone to vote me out. Fine, she thinks she can get rid of ME?! FLICKY FLOCKY FLICKA?! FINE! Let them ALL vote for me, I'll play my idol, all 6 of their votes won't count and my one vote for Jessica will single-handedly get her voted out! BOOM!" However, probably one minute into tribal council, I thought, "Well, if I do that, it's probably only going to save me for tonight and I'll be voted out. May as well show everyone I have the idol and because PMs are turned off, they'll have to draw the lines in front of everyone and say who they want to vote out now."

Let me tell you, though, I'm sure I was just as surprised seeing that you had an immunity necklace as you were to see that I had the HII. I never for even one second considered that ANYONE had one, let alone the person I wanted to vote out.
User avatar
Flicka
Jury
 
Posts: 384
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:41:37 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Cecilia » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:49:47 pm

I hope we're invited for Heroes vs Villains tbfh.

I'd be a villain.
User avatar
Cecilia
Jury
 
Posts: 830
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:41:16 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Rebecca » Thu Sep 10, 2015 5:49:48 am

Stephannie wrote:
Nate wrote:
Stephannie wrote:girls we all made the merge so I don't think any of us would necessarily qualify for a "gone-too-soon second chance" classification.

And personally I think I played a GOOD GAME, and Cassandra said it herself that she was "honored" to meet me because of my pre-merge reputation.


Also nearly might have survived my elimination if everyone pre-voted correctly. icon_no (though Jessica/Nate both had immunity so I'm not sure sure what would happen in a tie)


also Steph I think we're both now in the "screwed because somebody who's name starts with the letter R didn't vote in time" club.

icon_no

Nate, my plan was to vote you off icon_laughing

Stephannie, I'm sorry that happened
I was so sad to see you go :(((
Like I legit felt so freaking guilty
Image
User avatar
Rebecca
Jury
 
Posts: 363
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:43:24 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Nate » Thu Sep 10, 2015 11:09:29 am

Rebecca wrote:
Nate, my plan was to vote you off icon_laughing


God, thanks for ruining my second chance storyline Rebecca.
Now I'm going to actively attempt to forget it so I can feel robbed when I don't get picked.
User avatar
Nate
Jury
 
Posts: 666
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:42:26 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Liliana » Thu Sep 10, 2015 11:47:47 am

everyone here is posting essays about their gameplay and I'm just
User avatar
Liliana
Jury
 
Posts: 434
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:22:51 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Rebecca » Thu Sep 10, 2015 12:17:43 pm

Nate wrote:
Rebecca wrote:
Nate, my plan was to vote you off icon_laughing


God, thanks for ruining my second chance storyline Rebecca.
Now I'm going to actively attempt to forget it so I can feel robbed when I don't get picked.

Why did you think I wasn't going to vote you off?

I'm legit annoyed by how many people think I wasn't gaming in there. Just because I don't show up for tribals or don't actively share my plans doesn't mean I'm not gaming icon_laughing

There was no benefit for me if you stayed.
User avatar
Rebecca
Jury
 
Posts: 363
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:43:24 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Nate » Thu Sep 10, 2015 12:21:10 pm

Rebecca wrote:
Nate wrote:
Rebecca wrote:
Nate, my plan was to vote you off icon_laughing


God, thanks for ruining my second chance storyline Rebecca.
Now I'm going to actively attempt to forget it so I can feel robbed when I don't get picked.

Why did you think I wasn't going to vote you off?

I'm legit annoyed by how many people think I wasn't gaming in there. Just because I don't show up for tribals or don't actively share my plans doesn't mean I'm not gaming icon_laughing

There was no benefit for me if you stayed.


Tbf I was planning F3 you/me/rocky.
Also the biggest indicator was that one of Jeff/Vitinho said that "if you are waiting on Rebecca's vote you are fucked" and then after I was voted out, I thought "ah, that's what fucked me"
User avatar
Nate
Jury
 
Posts: 666
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:42:26 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Rebecca » Thu Sep 10, 2015 1:58:06 pm

Nate wrote:
Rebecca wrote:
Nate wrote:
God, thanks for ruining my second chance storyline Rebecca.
Now I'm going to actively attempt to forget it so I can feel robbed when I don't get picked.

Why did you think I wasn't going to vote you off?

I'm legit annoyed by how many people think I wasn't gaming in there. Just because I don't show up for tribals or don't actively share my plans doesn't mean I'm not gaming icon_laughing

There was no benefit for me if you stayed.


Tbf I was planning F3 you/me/rocky.
Also the biggest indicator was that one of Jeff/Vitinho said that "if you are waiting on Rebecca's vote you are fucked" and then after I was voted out, I thought "ah, that's what fucked me"

I think they just meant I wasn't gonna show up like I never did icon_yawn
User avatar
Rebecca
Jury
 
Posts: 363
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:43:24 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Cassandra » Thu Sep 10, 2015 2:40:02 pm

Liliana wrote:everyone here is campaigning to be brought back and I'm just

fixed
User avatar
Cassandra
Jury
 
Posts: 632
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:21:25 pm

Re: Who should come back?

Postby Nate » Thu Sep 10, 2015 8:09:54 pm

Cassandra wrote:
Liliana wrote:everyone here is campaigning to be brought back and I'm just

fixed


It worked for Wentworth...
User avatar
Nate
Jury
 
Posts: 666
Joined: Fri Aug 07, 2015 5:42:26 pm

Previous

Return to Ponderosa

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests
cron